a blog about news and politics by steve janke
 

Is Working Families planning to expand into the tricky business of user-generated content?

WorkingFamilies.ca is insisting that it is an independent organization, not tied to the Liberals, and that it is only discussing issues.

When you control a website, it is relatively easy to make sure you don't cross the line.

But once you invite your user base to contribute content, you have to be careful. If you've cultivated a rabidly partisan fan base, your delicately constructed facade of non-partisanship can quickly disintegrate as your users make votes and not issues the most important subject of discussion.

I bring this up because it looks like WorkingFamilies.ca might be planning a move in this direction.




WorkingFamilies.ca is at the centre of a controversy:

The Ontario Progressive Conservatives have asked Elections Ontario to investigate a group called the Working Families Coalition because of its close ties to Premier Dalton McGuinty's office.

In a 22-page letter yesterday to chief election officer John Hollins, PC Party president Blair McCreadie formally demanded a probe, suggesting the organization is not an independent pressure group but in effect works for the provincial Liberal party.

Key figures linked to the coalition play or have played senior roles for the Liberals, including re-election campaign director Don Guy, a pollster and former McGuinty chief of staff, and veteran Grit strategist Marcel Wieder.

The people running WorkingFamilies.ca insist that they are advertising independently of any political party:

In an interview with the Star, Wieder rejected the Conservatives' accusations. "I guess the ads we have on TV are getting to them," said the veteran political operative.

Working Families spokesperson Patrick Dillon, business manager of the Provincial Building and Construction Trades Council, insisted the coalition is "an independent third party" organization.

"We don't tell people who to vote for," said Dillon, defending the hiring of top Liberal insiders to prepare ads urging Ontarians to vote against Conservative candidates.

But is it just ads? What about deliberately organizing events and holding contests to get people directly involved, as opposed to merely running TV spots?

The reason I ask is because I found a whole bunch of interesting buttons and images on the WorkingFamilies server (in static/wfc/images, interspersed with images currently used on the site). These images are not currently being displayed on any active pages:

Working Families

There is a contest currently on the site, asking people to submit stories that discuss an issue that would help a voter decide how to vote:

Want to make a difference in this campaign? Think you have something to say? Worried that your concerns aren’t being heard? Produce a campaign ad the political Leaders won’t soon forget.

Tell us your story and help Ontarians decide how to vote in the upcoming provincial election on October 10th?

Whether it’s an issue that you think needs more attention, a personal story you think voters should hear, or a fact that needs to be heard, we are looking for fun, imaginative and thoughtful campaign ads that will help voters decide the outcome of the upcoming provincial election.

Stay tuned for more details on how you can enter this exciting contest.

Notice that the request is for stories, not for arguments for or against a particular political party.

Apparently they'll be looking for people to upload videos. And they'll be awarded points. People will be tracked as to how many points they've earned over the course of the campaign. What a point gets you is unclear right now. Presumably, though, they will have some sort of value.

There will be connections to blogs. There will be guest columns, and visitors will be able to post comments.

Working Families will facilitate events and meetups, acting as a focus point for activists to organize.

In the business, we call this user-generated content.

I applaud Working Families for embracing the Web 2.0 world. But a word of warning. When you open a site to UGC, you have to very careful about control. If videos are uploaded that explicitly advocate votes for the Liberals, if the means of awarding points is subjective and partisan instead of merely a measure of participation, if Conservatives are frozen out of using the "Meetup" function to organize events, if commentary on the site is uniformly pro-Liberal and dissenting voices are viciously flamed...you get the picture...Elections Ontario might very well decide that Working Families is indeed thinly disguised Liberal advertising site.


Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary


Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
 Working Families  WorkingFamilies.ca  Ontario  Ontario Liberal Party  Progressive Conservative Party  user-generated content  UGC  Web 2.0  Provincial Building and Construction Trades Council 


Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!


Trackbacks
URI: http://haloscan.com/tb/agwnblog/238217

Trackback Submission Form



 

Comments

Please keep us updated on this organization, Steve. WorkingFamilies may well turn out to be non-partisan. But, the proof will be in how arms-length from the Liberal Party it operates (or would be seen as operating by a person of reasonably normal intelligence).

Posted by: Brian in Calgary at August 24, 2007 12:48 PM



It would be interesting to see were this Working families outfit is coming from and were it intents to go.
Sofar I don't think that McGuinty and Ontario Liberal party can be trusted,but the proof is in the pudding, and not enough of it has been served.The PC of Ontario is correct to have this affair being looked into by the Elections Ontario officials.If that will reveal anything, remains to be seen.

Posted by: Jan at August 24, 2007 01:45 PM



If election Ontario rules this is fair, them some PC loyalist that is not being paid by the party would be allowed to do the same and begin third party advertising. Someone correct me if I am wrong on this scenrio. Mr. McGuinty on the tube 24 hours a day, saying i will not lower your taxes but I will not raise them either, here watch me sign this pledge. No campaign financing rules to worry about at all. The " officially not a part of the party " group with the most money wins. This might be an amusing election after all.

Posted by: Ken at August 24, 2007 03:16 PM



Oh for G*d's sake.

"Working Families" is a leftoid buzz word meaning families that need substitute daycare to take care of their kids, so that the State can bring them up to be good little uber-in-lockstep-jackboot-we-love-the-State goons.

Jack Layton uses the term all the time, implying that the NDP are the political party that honours "working families." Right, Jack. I'll make a note of that.

Well, I've got news for you, Mr. Layton and "Working Families." The jig's up. You're a bunch of partisan hacks and a lot of Canadian voters are getting wise to your agenda.

Thanks, Steve, for exposing these poseurs for what they are: brazen political, partisan hacks. I hope that Elections Ontario does the right thing and closes them down.

Posted by: 'been around the block at August 25, 2007 06:10 PM