Stephane Dion and the Liberals have issued a press release to tell the national press gallery and thus the rest of us that Mahmoud Abbas, the President of the Palestinian National Authority, is visiting to speak to the leader of the Liberal Party.
Problem is, it simply isn't true.
Update: When I got wind of the screw up, I figured that it was the fault of the Office of the Leader of the Opposition. It was their email, after all. But it wasn't their email after all, or more accurately, it was filtered through someone else. And I was really quite surprised to find out who it was.
Here's the press release:
Date: July 05
Time: 9:30
Paticipant(s): Honourable Stephane Dion Leader of the Opposition & Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian National AuthorityLocation: 409-S Centre Block
Subject: Photo -OpDate: 05 juillet
Heure: 9:30
Participant(s):L'honorable Stephane Dion chef de l'opposition & Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian National AuthorityEndroit: 409-S edifice du Centre
Sujet: Seance de photo
A photo-op with Mahmoud Abbas! Even as the Palestian territories are picking up the rubble left from the Fatah-Hamas civil war. Wow. Now that's a photo-op.
I didn't even realize Abbas was in North America. I mean, if he was visiting with Stephane Dion, leader of Canada's opposition, then certainly he would be meeting with President George W Bush and other people who can actually make a difference. I mean, seriously, Stephane Dion?
Something seems fishy about this.
Actually, the explanation is simple. The press release is wrong.
It is Mahmoud Abbas' son who is seeing Stephane Dion. Noteworthy, maybe, but it's not likely that the younger Abbas is working in any sort of official capacity. Abbas' two surviving sons (his eldest Mazen died of a heart attack) are in private business, and not officials in the PA.
In any case, Stephane Dion is not a meeting with the PNA President.
I bet someone in the Liberal Party press office is feeling pretty dumb.
Update:
A comment from reader Ted:
If the press release, says he is meeting with "Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian National Authority" and invites the press to attend the post-meeting photo op, on what basis do you claim he is in fact meeting with someone else altogether, let alone some specific individuals.
Seems to me the press, having been invited and however dumb you may think they are, might notice it is someone altogether different.
So why not throw us a bone of evidence instead of typical Janke speculation and spin?
On what basis do I claim that he is meeting with someone else? On the basis that I know it to be true. If you prefer, believe the Liberal Party press release until the Liberal Party issues a new media release that corrects the one I alreay told you was wrong:
Liberal Opposition Leader Stephane Dion today called on the Conservative government to restore official aid funding immediately to the Palestinian Authority, following a meeting with Yasser Abbas, special envoy of his father, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.
Oh, and it was a meeting with Abbas' son, like I said nearly four hours ago. Go figure. It does look like young Yasser is working on behalf of the PNA though he has no official role. I had thought otherwise, and I was wrong on that count. Of course, you can imagine just what it means that Mahmoud Abbas depends on his son to act as envoy instead of someone who actually works in the Palestinian government.
Significant Update:
In terms of the mistake and the correction, nothing changes. But it was who made the mistake that surprised me:
Hey Steve - long time no talk! Anyway, I just wanted to let you know that the Abbas screwup wasn't, in fact, the fault of the Liberal press office, but the folks at the Parliamentary Press Gallery, who actually typed up the notice in question - not unusual when it's a last-minute event, easier to just call the Gallery and have them put out a quickie no-frills advisory than issue a full release (and yes, government ministers and other opposition parties do the same thing when they hold a media event on short notice). Anyway, a correction went out no more than ten minutes after the initial release, and it explicitly stated that the fault was that of the gallery, and not OLO.
So the OLO calls the PPG to tell them about the photo op, and in the process, a press release on behalf of the OLO (and looking like it was written by the OLO) is issued with a really silly mistake that the PPG took responsibility for.
So my apologies to the OLO -- I missed the correction, and I figured your press release was written by you, and so any mistakes were yours as well. Not the case, as it turns out. And to the Parliamentary Press Gallery, come on! Abbas is a bit too busy right now to be visiting Canadian opposition politicians. I can only imagine the number of people at the PPG reading the release, screwing up their faces, and asking, "Are you sure this is right? Abbas is here? In Ottawa?"
But I learned something I didn't know before, and that is the role the PPG plays is preparing these releases. Knowing that will help in the future when I see more questionable releases.
Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary
Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
Stephane Dion Mahmoud Abbas Canada Palestinian National Authority Liberal Party
Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!
Next he's having a meeting with Ricky Bobby to discuss NASCAR sponsorship.
Posted by: rations at July 5, 2007 05:10 PM
If the press release, says he is meeting with "Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian National Authority" and invites the press to attend the post-meeting photo op, on what basis do you claim he is in fact meeting with someone else altogether, let alone some specific individuals.
Seems to me the press, having been invited and however dumb you may think they are, might notice it is someone altogether different.
So why not throw us a bone of evidence instead of typical Janke speculation and spin?
Posted by: Ted at July 5, 2007 05:38 PM
I just heard a rumour Steffi is meeting with a "Captain Kirk" of the Starship Enterprise.
Not sure if he is an important fellow for Steffi to court favours from, but one never knows.
Posted by: Fred at July 5, 2007 06:05 PM
...or there's a lot of homeless people in Ottawa to visit too.
Posted by: tomax7 at July 5, 2007 06:11 PM
:::If the press release, says he is meeting with "Mahmoud Abbas President of the Palestinian National Authority" and invites the press to attend the post-meeting photo op, on what basis do you claim he is in fact meeting with someone else altogether, let alone some specific individuals.:::
How about this from the Liberal web site:
"Liberal Opposition Leader Stéphane Dion today called on the Conservative government to restore official aid funding immediately to the Palestinian Authority, following a meeting with Yasser Abbas, special envoy of his father, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas." - http://www.liberal.ca/story_12954_e.aspx
Posted by: Denis at July 5, 2007 06:20 PM
A Liberal, Lying, in our cities, on our streets ...
THIS IS UNFAIR!!!!
Posted by: ZiLLa at July 5, 2007 08:09 PM
And suck up Pierre Bourque now posts it on his site as the Gospel. Go figure!
Nothing like Janke and Bourque manufacturing some news.
Posted by: sam at July 5, 2007 09:48 PM
So the Parliamentary Press Gallery works directly for the Liberal Party of Toronto. Makes sense.
Posted by: philanthropist at July 6, 2007 01:27 AM
Why would this business-minded son go to Canada seeking the release of millions in government aid money and speak to the Leader of the Opposition rather than the Prime Minister of Canada??
Just wondering?
Posted by: Neil Davy at July 6, 2007 01:48 AM
is this blogger bored with life, or does he actually find analyzing PPG press releases interesting?
i thought he actually had something interesting to say
Posted by: flight147 at July 6, 2007 01:57 AM
RE: JANKE'S CORRECTION UPDATE
See the dangers of jumping to your typical speculation, Steve? Your uber-partisanship shows through and it undermines your credibility. Maybe you are right and the many quick excuses for your mistake are justified. But the press release was corrected by the PPG just 10 minutes later!
So either you were deliberately trying to smear the Liberals with information you knew to be false (which I doubt, frankly, because you DID post the "not my fault" whine of a correction) or it shows once again how your speculative way of writing is a character flaw.
Even in your correction, you continue to make errors and cheap partisan potshots. The email you re-published clearly indicates last minute "quickie no-frills advisories" from all politicians including government, so it's not just an opposition thing and its not for all press releases.
Posted by: Ted at July 6, 2007 09:14 AM
Even in your correction, you continue to make errors and cheap partisan potshots.
Of course, Ted, you would never make errors or cheap partisan potshots yourself.
Posted by: Brian in Calgary at July 6, 2007 02:05 PM
To paraphrase Ted, "Hey kettle, you're black!"
Posted by: DarrenK at July 6, 2007 03:52 PM
The word imaginary does bring back memories, Chretien had an imaginary meeting with a street person. It's not surprising his prodigy would have the same affliction.
If you can't get the real thing, imagination can be the next best thing to stroke the ego and grab headlines.
Must say, if I were choosing to meet with some imaginary figure I'd go for a real doozie.
Posted by: Libby at July 6, 2007 06:03 PM
Maybe Stephane can sent a family member to meet with the opposition in the West Bank / Gaza. If not a family member send Taliban Jack
Posted by: George at July 7, 2007 05:13 AM