a blog about news and politics by steve janke
 

Transport Canada has been on the tire issue since Monday, but no recall yet

Word from the Globe and Mail today that Transport Canada has been looking at Chinese tire problem since Monday. But until the manufacturer tells Transport Canada that there is a problem, there is little Transport Canada can do, even as in the US, they are preparing to recall nearly half-a-million tires with a potentially deadly defect.




Transport Canada is aware that there is a potentially serious problem with tires made at the Hangzhou factory in China:

An investigation by Transport Canada has discovered that at least one Canadian wholesaler imported tires that U.S. authorities ordered recalled earlier this week from a company in China.

Transport Canada spokeswoman Jessie Chauhan said the ministry became aware of the U.S. recall on Monday through an Associated Press story.

Even though 450,000 of the light truck radials manufactured by Hangzhou Zhongce Rubber Co. were recalled by the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Canadian officials do not have the legal authority to recall the tires until they receive a notice of defect from the manufacturer.

Given that Hangzhou has denied that there is anything wrong, that notice might be a long time in coming. The law in Canada might be the same as in the US, in which the importer can act in the role of the manufacturer and deliver the notice, but so far, that hasn't happened:

In a written statement, Hangzhou Zhongce said its tires met all U.S. safety standards. "We have not found the faults cited by FTS," it read.

Transport Canada says two Canadian wholesalers have imported tires from the Chinese company, one of which was a West Coast dealer that buys products from Foreign Tire Sales. Transport Canada officials said the company imported tires meant for passenger cars to Canada, none of which were on the U.S. recall list.

The other company, Mississauga-based Rakla Tires Inc., imported some of the tires that were on the list, which are designed for pickup trucks, SUVs and cube vans.

In an interview with The Globe and Mail, president Aziz Rakla said his company stands behind its products, but refused to comment further. "We have not had any claims or issues regarding these tires in Canada," he said. "We are working with the government to gather additional facts, and we will advise you of any additional actions." Mr. Rakla refused to say how many of the tires the company has imported or whether any were sold in Canada.

So we now know that we could have bought these tires in Canada, though we don't know how long these tires have been for sale. We also don't know is whether we're sharing the road with any vehicles with these tires right now. And it appears also that even as we watch American authorities tell consumers to remove these tires from their vehicles ahead of the official recall to start Monday, action in Canada is going to have to wait, at least for a bit.

Contrast this to the forcefulness of the response to the question of defective tires in Connecticut:

Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal today announced he is investigating the distribution and sale of defective Chinese-made tires in Connecticut and warned tire dealers that they risk violating state law if they continue selling them.

"We are preparing to take immediate measures beginning with strong investigative steps to stop sales of these defective, dangerous tires and compensate consumers for damage -- similar to action we took in the Firestone case," Blumenthal said.

"Dealers who sell these perilously unsafe products should be on notice that they can be held liable for violating our state law. An immediate recall should be ordered by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

"We are contacting other states to begin a joint, multistate investigation and action.

"We will have three goals: recovering money for consumer victims, removing tires from the road and stopping illegal practices. Tread separation can cause horrendous fatal accidents, particularly on SUVs and vans, and a recall is necessary immediately. The Chinese manufacturer -- as well as the American distributor -- should cease selling and marketing these tires, which lack a layer of rubber between the steel belts necessary for durability."

Let's keep watching the story develop.


Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary


Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
 NHTSA  Westlake  Telluride  YKS  Compass  tire  recall  FTS  Hangzhou Zhongce Rubber  Transport Canada 


Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!


Trackbacks
URI: http://haloscan.com/tb/agwnblog/231717

Trackback Submission Form



 

Comments

Don't they know about the wise old saw, err on the side of caution? Lives are at stake here. Whether you have them or others on the road have them, blowing a tire at high speed can take out a few people.

WHAT PART ABOUT UNSAFE TIRES DON'T THEY UNDERSTAND?

WHO ARE THEY PROTECTING, THE PEOPLE OF CANADA OR FREAKING CHINA?

Anyone else getting paranoid about ANYTHING from China?

C'mon Mr. Cannon, pull the lead out, get in gear.

Posted by: Libby at June 28, 2007 06:42 AM



It looks like on both sides of the border, the law puts much of the responsibility on the manufacturer to get the ball rolling. Regulators have their hands tied.

Posted by: Steve Janke at June 28, 2007 07:21 AM



I think we have all been under the assumption that the gov't looks after us when it comes to consumer health and safety. Now we are learning that that's not really true. We all need to assume personal responsibilty for ourselves and our families and become informed and vigilant about what we buy.
I have often wondered how China can manufacture and ship an overwhelming variety of goods for such cheap prices. Now we are starting to find out and it's not pretty.

Posted by: muttsrus at June 28, 2007 09:30 AM



If the governments have no control over safety and quality of goods entering the country as trade it high time they did.
Government signs trade deals with them.

Looks like we all better stop buying cheap crap from China or anywhere else, it looks like the only option.

Posted by: Libby at June 28, 2007 09:46 AM



That's too bad. How do I know if my car's tires are safe or not?

Posted by: wedding at June 28, 2007 11:13 AM



Many at TRANSPORT QANNADDA must be VERY UPSET at having their sleep disturbed like this, with citizens' requests for action.

Posted by: Feldwebel Wolfenstool at June 28, 2007 11:28 AM



...how far back will the recall go? I bought tires a couple of years ago, so probably not affected, but they are starting to look thin and I need to get new ones.

I always bought Goodyear, so hopefully they are still quality. How about Koyo?

Posted by: tomax7 at June 28, 2007 12:10 PM



"I bought tires a couple of years ago, so probably not affected, but they are starting to look thin and I need to get new ones."

My understanding is that the US authorities are looking at tires going back to 2002.

Posted by: Steve Janke at June 28, 2007 12:59 PM



Notice how that while consumers may be blowing tires en masse on the highways, the manufacturer has to admit to a problem before any government action can occur.

I see the US FDA is now going after antibiotic laced fish imports from China. Health Canada must be waiting for people to show up at hospital with antibiotic resistant infections. Oh sorry. Hospitals are already filled with antibiotic resistant bacteria. My bad.

We can in part thank Jean Cretien and his Team Canada for opening up the floodgates to this crap.

There is probably lots of good quality product in China. What we have is a myriad of storefront "import-export" companies who only look at the bottom line with no concept of liability or quality, or even an understanding of the product they promote. Call it "Saturday night specials".

I put new tires on my truck last year. Purchased from a reputable local tire dealer. Turns out they were made in China. They are not manufactured by this Hangzhou company. I think wooden wagon wheels would be a softer ride.

Posted by: john at June 29, 2007 06:21 AM