Breaking: Ersatz Colgate toothpaste in the United States might contain DEG. And I just bought a suspicious tube of toothpaste in my local dollar store in Canada.
The latest outrage from China is the export of toothpaste using a poisonous component of antifreeze, diethylene glycol, as a thickener. The FDA has blocked all imports of Chinese-made toothpaste into the United States.
The FDA also recommended that consumers with tubes of Chinese-made toothpaste dispose of the products immediately.
I use Colgate toothpaste, and I checked the label. Made in Mexico. Sounds fine, except for the fact that in this interview, an extremely senior Chinese Communist Party official, Cheng Siwei, brags about how Colgate toothpaste used by Americans is made in China.
Curious. And disturbing.
The Food and Drug Administration yesterday warned consumers not to use toothpaste made in China after finding tubes tainted with a poisonous chemical used in antifreeze and brake fluid.
The FDA said last week it was testing all imports of toothpaste from China for diethylene glycol after reports surfaced that Chinese toothpaste containing it had been exported to the Dominican Republic, Panama and Australia.
The agency yesterday also instituted an import alert to prevent the entry of toothpaste containing the deadly chemical into the U.S.
Officials said U.S. inspectors detained one shipment of toothpaste at the border and found and tested products at a distribution center in Los Angeles and at two stores -- a Miami Dollar Plus and a Todo A Peso in Puerto Rico.
The brands in question are not the big ones. These are cheap knockoffs that go by the name Cooldent and Superdent and Oral Bright, typically sold in dollar stores.
The big manufacturers, such as Colgate, a division Colgate-Palmolive, make their toothpaste elsewhere. The tube I have says "Made in Mexico".
I should have left it there. Instead, I decided to do a bit of checking, and now I'm worried. Made in Mexico? If so, why would this very senior Chinese official, Cheng Siwei, brag about Colgate toothpaste being made in China for export to the United States?
PAUL SOLMAN: We were here to interview one of China's current top leaders, Cheng Si-wei, an economist in the 2,000-year-old tradition of Confucian scholar politicians.
The author of 28 books, Vice Chairman Cheng is also known as the godfather of venture capital in China.
CHENG SIWEI: Yes. Some people told me, you know, average Americans, you know, they use actually now in their daily life, they use many cheap Chinese goods from morning to the evening; when they woke up, their blanket is made in China. When they wear shoes to go jogging, the shoes, Nike shoes, made in China.
PAUL SOLMAN: Nike.
CHENG SIWEI: Yes. And they use a toothbrush, it's made in China. The Colgate Toothpaste is made in China.
PAUL SOLMAN: Colgate Toothpaste is made in China?
CHENG SIWEI: Certainly. American people are really benefiting from cheaper Chinese goods.
That was in October 2005. Maybe that was once true, but is no longer true. Or maybe Siwei was lying, or just ignorant of where toothpaste used by Americans is made. Or maybe he's telling the truth -- that the toothpaste, or major components of the product, is manufactured in China and then repackaged or otherwise reworked in some way in Mexico as a final step, with Mexico therefore being identified as the country of manufacture.
Does Cheng Siwei know what he's talking about? He was Vice Minister of the Chemical Industry from 1994 through 1997, and is currently a vice-chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, the de facto legislative body of the People's Republic of China. He speaks with the authority of the Chinese government.

Feel free to steal this badge.
Check out what Canadian bloggers have written about Chinese imports
Results will open in a new window.
Check out other entries from the Colgate toothpaste category
Results will open in a new window.
Check out what Canadian bloggers have posted about Colgate toothpaste
Results will open in a new window.
Check out what has been written about Colgate toothpaste on the web
Results will open in a new window.
Check out other entries from the Pet Food Recall category
Results will open in a new window.
Check out other entries from the True Crime category
Results will open in a new window.
Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary
Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
China toothpaste diethylene glycol FDA Colgate
Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!
Gotta love that global marketing...why it just brings a 'fresh brushed' smile to one's face !
I'm quite sure that the practice of packaging ingredients from wherever and labelling the product as being made in an 'acceptable' country: thereby circumventing all manner of regulations is far more widespread than may be imagined.
As usual, money doesn't talk...it swears and once again proves that there is no real accountability in modern day economics...nor scrupples!
Good post Steve.
Posted by: Simon at June 5, 2007 02:03 PM
My tube of Crest just says "Dist. by/par" Proctor&Gamble, Toronto, Canada.
They do not say where it is made, although the ingredients list appears quite comprehensive.
Posted by: john at June 5, 2007 02:36 PM
I have said it from the beginning...Made in USA/Product of Canada does NOT describe the origion of the components of any product!
Posted by: ZiLLa at June 5, 2007 03:53 PM
Show me someone who has to buy 0ff-brand toothpaste in dollar stores and I'll show you someone who is either living off government welfare, is chronically underployed due to government interference in the job market, or whose after-tax, after-inflation income leaves them scrambling to survive. That's what sux about big government - they claim they're taking all your money because they're making you safe, but all they do is make your life more dangerous.
And did you think that the only commies you have to worry about are the ones that call themselves "communists"? US Government bans private beef testing. Err, technically that's fascism, because the government is conniving to protect certain favored big businesses. But basically it's the same scam as in China (and Canada).
Posted by: at June 5, 2007 09:01 PM
show me someone who buys off brand toothpaste I'll show you a cheapskate! my crest costs just over a couple bucks and lasts forever at 2 brushes (promise MOM!) a day. oh for the good old days when we worried about too much flouride.
Posted by: kelly at June 5, 2007 10:16 PM
I called Proctor and Gamble regarding the Crest toothpaste and they told me it was made in the US. When I asked about their other products the CSR I was talked to said "I don't know about any of those" and hung up.
Posted by: Jim Wilkinson at June 6, 2007 11:52 AM
kelly - "show me someone who buys off brand toothpaste I'll show you a cheapskate!"
...obviously kelly's never had kids or lived on low income wages.
I'm so glad I don't eat from sky blue colour with yellow print boxes any more.
Posted by: tomax7 at June 9, 2007 08:46 AM
*
-- BEIJING -- In a new twist on a widening scandal, China admitted Monday that unscrupulous dealers had sold fake blood protein to dozens of hospitals and phar macies, threatening the lives of patients and reportedly killing at least one person.
*
Posted by: neo at June 12, 2007 12:33 AM