Season three of the new Battlestar Galactica has wrapped up with another jaw-dropping season cliffhanger. Paul Wells of Macleans magazine shares his opinion, and I feel compelled to offer a rebuttal.
From Paul Wells' blog on something really important -- Battlestar Galactica:
Boy, that version of that tune at the end of last night's season finale was pretty lame. Excellent idea, though: if you're hearing the tune, you must be close to...uh, something.
So do we think Kara's the last you-know-what? Seems too easy, somehow.
Anyway, I was getting a bit tired of the whole thing, but I'm gonna stick in there for the beginning of next season, anyway. Unlike Lost or The X-Files, this show actually goes somewhere. I think.
Um, it's going to Earth. McFly? McFly?!
OK, I'm just kidding with Paul.
Seriously, I don't do entertainment on this blog often, but I've watched both the original series and the re-imagined version and enjoyed them both immensely. Unlike a lot of fans, I was eager to see the new version, having no qualms whatsover about the changes to the series. Let's face it -- the original series was crap. I mean, it was fun crap, to be sure, but crappy nonetheless.
I think there was only one moment of transcendence in the old series, and that was the two-parter with Count Iblis, played by Patrick Macnee. Iblis, who is the Devil, visits Baltar in his cell. The traitor Baltar had surrendered himself to the humans, seemingly at the contrivance of Iblis. In any case, Baltar is shocked -- not so much that Iblis somehow passed through the bars to be in the cell with him, but that Iblis' voice was the same as the Imperious Leader of the Cylons.
That's absurd, says Iblis with a grin, since it would mean I would have had to be there a thousand yarns ago when the Leader's voice was programmed. Or words to that effect.
In that moment, the old Battlestar Galactica showed what television could be like. That Patrick Macnee lent his voice to the Imperious Leader in the series pilot was pure serendipity. I've never read anywhere that they planned to bring Macnee back to play Iblis. But when he was cast in the role, the writers had a chance to eliminate a nagging problem in the series at a stroke, but to take that chance required some guts. They took it. That the original Cylons were a mechanical race created by a reptilian species long since dead (at the hands of their own creation) was a hackneyed cliche plagued with unanswered questions, but safe for television in 1979. However, by highlighting Macnee's distinctive voice, an entirely new interpretation was suggested -- that the Cylons (the organic ones) had made a deal with Iblis, perhaps for eternal life, and in classic devilish fashion, the contract was perverted and the Cylon souls became trapped in their machines. A living hell, as it were. Gutsy, especially since they didn't explain it in so many words -- it was just left there for the viewer to figure out. Since when were TV viewers treated with that much respect in those days?
Hey, that's just my interpretation of that little scene, but in all 26 episodes of the original series, it was the one scene I'll always remember. The new series? It seems like every episode has one or two great scenes like it. Kara "Starbuck" Thrace, back from the dead, flying alongside Lee "Apollo" Adama as the humans prepare to confont the Cylons is just the last of many in a great second season.
If you've been watching the new Battlestar Galactica, you know what I mean. If you haven't, it's your loss. Like Twin Peaks, it is redefining episodic television, especially sci-fi television. The ships, the tactics, the characters, their motivations -- it all makes sense and hangs together in a way that grabs you. I enjoy sci-fi, so no surprise that I like it. But that it is one of my wife's favourite programs tells you how effective the series has been at getting viewers outside of the sci-fi demographic.
Now the long six-month wait for season four. Well, more blogging to fill in the time, I suppose.
Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary
Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
Battlestar Galactica Battlestar Pegasus Count Iblis Cylon Kara Thrace Lee Adama Starbuck Apollo Twin Peaks Patrick Macnee Baltar Paul Wells MacLeans
Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!
Sorry I'm a sci-fi fan and everything but I watched a couple episodes and while the plot is intriging it takes way to fracing long for them to make a point... and then there's the fracing writing... like frac man... why the fracing need to create a whole new fracing set of swears. that arn't "really" swearing. The fracing pathetic attempt to avoid fracing censorship is really fracing obvious...
sorry I watched a few and the "frac's" just started grating on the fracing nerves after about 5 minutes... havn't watched since.
Posted by: Sierra at March 27, 2007 09:16 AM
Is Lorne Greene still on that show? (Sorry, couldn't help myself.)
Posted by: Joan Tintor at March 27, 2007 10:55 AM
Loved the season finale. The start of S3 was interesting as it had the whole "occupation force there to help the humans" and human insurgents. It hit a little closer to the "current events" mark than we've come to expect for a sci-fi show. S3 was a little light on the ship battles and special effects but it was very entertaining.
By the way, it's not six months to Season 4, it's nine months. The new season won't start until January but there is rumored to be one or two of "prequel" shows set for the fall.
I'll just have to wait for the S3 DVD set to keep me occupied.
Posted by: Darren at March 27, 2007 11:07 AM
And not only that, but the Iblis episode is being re-run this week on Space channel.
Posted by: Mike at March 27, 2007 04:59 PM
"frac" is a nod to the original program, which used the same word in the same way (though a bit less obviously). Still, it was a cute way around the censors of the time -- there was no way not to use the same word now.
Lorne Greene is watching from above. Richard Hatch is, of course, a series regular, which gives the new series a lot of credibility, since Hatch (aka Apollo from the original) has been a driving force for a new series ever since the original was canceled. Even though his view of the new BSG was never picked up, the producers of the new show were ecstatic to have him on their version.
Posted by: Steve Janke at March 27, 2007 07:37 PM