Relevant Links




Your Ad Here

Jumping to the defence of Belinda

Robert Fife drops the bombshell in a story about the appointment of Martha Hall Findlay to be the candidate of the riding of Willowdale in Toronto:

Fife said observers expect Dion to continue appointing women to prominent ridings in anticipation of a coming election.

However, the political future of Belinda Stronach -- one of the Liberals' most prominent female MPs -- has come into question in Ottawa recently, Fife said.

"She has been more or less eclipsed since the Liberal leadership race. She doesn't have a critic's job, she rarely ever gets up in the House of Commons to ask questions, and people here in Ottawa are wondering whether she is going to run again for the party," Fife said. [emphasis added]

"Her office and she herself insist that she is, but there are some doubts here."

She doesn't have a critic's job? Is Fife right about that?

Here's the full listing of the Shadow Cabinet as it appears in Wikipedia:

Portfolio Shadow Minister
Leader of the Opposition Hon. Stephane Dion (2006–)
Deputy Leader of the Opposition Michael Ignatieff[2] (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food Hon. Wayne Easter (2006–)
Critic for the Minister for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency Jean-Claude D'Amours (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Canadian Heritage Tina Keeper (2007–)
Critic for the Canadian International Development Agency Hon. Mark Eyking (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Omar Alghabra (2007–)
Critic for Competitiveness and the New Economy Hon. Belinda Stronach (2006–)
Critic for Consumer Affairs and Consular Services Hon. Dan McTeague (2007–)
Critic for Crown Corporations Borys Wrzesnewskyj (2007–)
Critic for Democratic Reform Hon. Stephen Owen (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of the Environment David McGuinty (2007–)
Critic for the Minister responsible for the Federal
Economic Development Initiative for Northern Ontario
Ken Boshcoff (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Finance Hon. John McCallum (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans Scott Simms (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Foreign Affairs Hon. Ujjal Dosanjh (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Foreign Affairs (Asia-Pacific) Hon. Raymond Chan (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Health Bonnie Brown (2006–)
Opposition House Leader Hon. Ralph Goodale (2006–)
Deputy Opposition House Leader Hon. Lucienne Robillard (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development Mike Savage (2006–)
Critic for Human Rights Hon. Irwin Cotler (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Indian Affairs Hon. Anita Neville (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Industry Hon. Scott Brison (2007–)
Critic for Infrastructure Hon. Mauril Belanger (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs Bernard Patry (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of International Trade Hon. Navdeep Bains (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Justice
      and Attorney General
Hon. Marlene Jennings (2007–)
Critic for La Francophonie and Official Languages Raymonde Folco (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Labour Mario Silva (2007–)
Critic for Multiculturalism Colleen Beaumier (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of National Defence Hon. Denis Coderre (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of National Revenue Hon. Judy Sgro (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Natural Resources Mark Holland (2006–)
Critic for Northern Development Hon. Larry Bagnell (2006–)
Critic for the Pacific Gateway Don Bell (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Public Safety
and Emergency Preparedness
and Public Health
Hon. Sue Barnes (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of the Economic Development
Agency for the Regions of Quebec
Marcel Proulx (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Public Works and Government Services Pablo Rodriguez (2007–)
Leader of the Opposition in the Senate Celine Hervieux-Payette (2007–)
Critic for Rural Affairs Hon. Charles Hubbard (2007–)
Critic for Science and Research Hon. Maurizio Bevilacqua (2007–)
Critic for Seniors, the Disabled and the Social Economy Hon. Carolyn Bennett (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Social Development Ruby Dhalla (2007–)
Critic for Minister for Sport and Vancouver Olympics Hon. Hedy Fry (2007–)
Critic for Status of Women Hon. Maria Minna (2007–)
Critic for the Minister of Transport Hon. Joe Volpe (2006–)
Critic for the President of the Treasury Board Hon. Raymond Simard (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Veterans Affairs Hon. Albina Guarnieri (2006–)
Critic for the Minister of Western Economic Diversification Sukh Dhaliwal (2007–)
Chief Opposition Whip Hon. Karen Redman (2006–)
Deputy Opposition Whip Marcel Proulx (2007–)

She is still listed in that position in the current Liberal Party caucus document.

But Fife might have misspoken. Though Belinda has a critic position, it is also true that she does not sit on any caucus committees. She is the critic for Competitiveness and the New Economy, but she is not on the Committee on Economic Prosperity, or the Committee on Canada and the World.

That is odd, and might support the argument that Belinda has been marginalized for some reason.

It's a subtle point, but I think it is a point that needs to be set straight.

Your Ad Here
Relevant Links




Your Ad Here

Create Commons License 2.5
Angry in the Great White North by Steve Janke is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.5 Canada License. Based on a work at stevejanke.com.
Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict
[Valid Atom 1.0]
Valid CSS!