a blog about news and politics by steve janke
 

Environmental lobbying on the sly?

Young people are being encouraged to "adopt" an MP to push for action on the issue of climate change.

My question is just where does democratic participation end and formal lobbying begin. Has this group crossed the line?

And who is behind this group in the first place?




It is one thing to go to local MP. It is quite another to become part of a structured and organized effort to influence the decisions of the government as a whole:

But a new campaign will see some of Canada's younger constituents calling the shots by challenging members of Parliament to take action on climate change - once they decide which MP they plan to adopt.

There's no need for anyone to pack their bags: the Adopt-an-MP campaign, organized by the Canadian Youth Climate Coalition, won't see elected representatives forced to move house.

Instead, it encourages Canadian youth to select an MP whom they will educate about global warming on an ongoing basis, putting the heat on politicians to take a leadership role in making climate change a top priority on Parliament Hill.

While youth are encouraged to take their local MPs under the wings, the coalition will have a top 10 board posted of more high-profile adoptees, including the federal party leaders and environment minister, that individuals are encouraged to adopt in "large numbers,'' Hudema said.

Can someone explain to me just how this is not a lobbying effort, and as such requires these young people to register in the federal lobbyists database?

Who exactly is behind the CYCC?

COUNCIL

In response to the coalition's growth and evolution, the council is currently being restructured. In the future, it will act as a large decision-making body and will include one representative from each member organization as well as regional representatives from local CYCC groups.

Not much help there. How about the website itself?

Domain ourclimate.ca
Registrant Name Jeca Glor-Bell
Registrar Netfirms, Inc.
Renewal Date 2007/09/24
Date approved 2006/09/24
Last changed 2006/09/28

And who is Jeca Glor-Bell?

The Sierra Club of Canada appointed national board members through its chapters until 2003, when the first national board election by members was held.

Jeca Glor-Bell (Ontario)

Jeca Glor-Bell graduated from Trent University in 2003 with a Honours B.A., Environmental Resource Studies and International Development Studies. She has been working with the Sierra Youth Coalition for the last 2 years as the Ontario Sustainable Campuses Coordinator.

And, of course, the Sierra Club is dedicated to influencing the government to take major action on the issue of climate change:

The energy used to drive our economy has a huge impact on our atmosphere. Sierra Club of Canada advocates a sensible mix of solutions: the highest possible energy efficiency, deployment of renewables (wind and solar), reduction in the use of fossil fuels, the phaseout of nuclear power and a shift to the new, innovative technologies (hybrid and fuel cells) to move people and goods around.

Ultimately, the threats of climate change, species extinction, toxic contamination and deforestation are symptoms of a larger problem. Pursuing the solutions, the economic and institutional shifts to deliver a reduced ecological footprint, reduce population growth and assist countries in the developing world to find a path that avoids our mistakes is the work of out programme for a "transition to a sustainable economy".

So a board member of the Sierra Club creates an organization that aims to lobby the highest levels of government on the issue of climate change using youth.

A less charitable interpretation is that the Sierra Club is using children as a way of avoiding the closer scruitiny under which formal lobbyists operate.

But then environmentalists would never do such a thing.


Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary


Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
 CYCC  Canadian Youth Climate Coalition  Canada  climate change  Sierra Club  Jeca Glor-Bell 


Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!


Trackbacks
URI: http://haloscan.com/tb/agwnblog/218526

Trackback Submission Form



 

Comments

Nice bit of research. Of course, the whole post is predicated on having identified who registered the site. This may or may not be linkable to Sierra, but where there is smoke there is likely fire.

Ms. Jeca Glor-Bell should probably withdraw gracefully, or supply Canadians with an explanation of how this isn't lobbying. Comment from the Sierra Club would be interesting too, just so the public has positions on the record.

Posted by: Erik Sorenson at March 11, 2007 01:29 PM



Another link:

Rosa Kouri, Sierra Youth Coalition Coordinator - Sierra
Rosa Kouri, Treasurer - CYCC

Posted by: Erik Sorenson at March 11, 2007 01:54 PM



Classic! "Alexa McDonough's office called about how well their adoption is going. They mentioned it to the entire NDP caucus, who ALL want to be adopted"

Of course they do.. Won't someone please give Olivia Chow a good home?

Posted by: Levesque at March 11, 2007 02:15 PM



Does this motivate any thinking person:

"Isn't the only hope for the planet that industrialized civilizations
COLLAPSE? Isn't it our responsibility to BRING THAT ABOUT?"
That folks is from the great mind of one Maurice Strong who hangs
out a great deal of time in polluted China wheeling and dealing.

Another quote of interest is from Michael Ignatieff who stated
"As a practical matter of politics nobody knows what Kyoto is or
what it commits us to."

Is this proof that Dion is not a Nobody because he still spouts Kyoto
as his main cause or will it dog him to obscurity as it should?

Posted by: Liz J at March 11, 2007 03:21 PM




Sierra Youth Coalition Manifesto:
fix the world by "reduce population growth " and "assist countries in the developing world to find a path that avoids our mistakes" ??
That's pretty scary stuff for youths to pursue.
Adopt an MP ? Reduce population ?
Save the planet before its too late?
I guess their heart is in the right place.

Posted by: banjotom at March 11, 2007 04:15 PM



I'm with Liz, this stinks of Maurice Strong.
Where the Sierra Club is, Maurice sent them.

Posted by: Durward at March 11, 2007 07:57 PM



So, maybe all commentors should adopt one of these members and inform them of how they are wrong. Send them all info from any letter to the editor, columnist, whatever. Maybe they should also get the suzuki poll. Someone post the names of the members and an e-mail. Give them a taste of their own medicine.
We also have to make every effort to get this org registered as a lobbyist.

Posted by: maryT at March 11, 2007 08:18 PM



If they want to "reduce population growth" I have one thing to say to them: "Okay, you first!"

Posted by: Proud Albertan at March 11, 2007 11:47 PM



We have adopted Scott Brison and already have our adoption certificate and our "first assignment" a la mission impossible. They didn't even ask how old we were!!! We are apparently to take our marching orders from a Mike Hudema
http://itsgettinghotinhere.org/author/mike-hudema/page/2/

It is too funny for words!

Posted by: dubya dubya at March 12, 2007 08:17 PM



cheap cialis

Posted by: kriss@aol.com at May 23, 2007 05:17 AM