Gerry Nicholls gives use some more on the GO Transit "Stephen Harper eats babies" incident.
More news from Gerry Nicholls on the baby-eating ad:
She [Gerry's wife] called Go [sic] Transit and they told her the Harper message was a result of somebody hacking into the computer system.
The ad was the scrolling "Stephen Harper Eats Babies" message on the LED display in the car. A hack is interesting. I would guess that the advertising system used in the GO trains is wireless -- new messages are uploaded as required, probably using a short-range low-power transmitter located on the platform at the stations. That means someone with a short-range transmitter and a laptop could, with the right knowledge, rewrite the message, but probably only on a car-by-car basis.
If Exclusive Advertising and GO Transit were more forthcoming, they could tell us how many cars were affected, and when. That would tell us if more than one person was involved, or if it was one person affecting one car, or one person moving from car to car and train to train.
But that being said, it does not say much for the security protocols in place. I think Exclusive Advertising has some explaining to do, both to GO Transit and to the advertisers. Exclusive Advertising charges $8,690 to an advertiser to run a 15-second scrolling LED ad on 790 cars for one month. Advertisers should be concerned that they are getting their money's worth, and that their ads aren't subject to corruption.
Of course, the hack story is convenient because it externalizes the blame. Some soothing words about upgraded security, and we move on. I would like to see an explanation of how the hack was done, just so that I can be convinced that it is a plausible explanation. The more plausible explanation was that this was an example of employee mischief. That would be very embarrassing to Exclusive Advertising.
Update: Gerry got this email from GO Transit:
Dear Mr. Nicholls:
Thank you for taking the time to contact us regarding your experience while travelling on the Lakeshore West Rail service.
Please be assured that GO Transit is aware of the electronic signage and is in the process of rectifying the situation. GO Transit does not endorse the expressed opinion.
Thank you for your concerns.
Sincerely,
Trudy Taylor-Steele
Customer Service Representative
At least now there is no doubt that it happened as Gerry described it. Still the answer is lacking in detail. As an advertiser, I would be demanding some details to understand the likelihood of my paid ads being subverted or pre-empted.
Skew my story on Skewz.com
Rate political news for their bias, read related stories, and leave your own skewed commentary
Search for more opinions from Canadian bloggers on these related keywords
GO Transit hacker Stephen Harper Gerry Nicholls
Sphere presents related news articles and blog posts
Sphere It!
I've worked with a similar company as an editor for sports info company, and we used pager frequencies to transmit. If that's the way they transmit, the case suggesting a hacker just got a lot more tenuous. You'd need to know the "pin" number, the dialer number and potentially have the dialer software.
The other options would be a hand-held remote for the LED sign, or a hard-wired terminal in a back area on the train. The latter is doubtful, and I'm not sure if the remotes are linked to the individual sign or not. If they aren't, then the case against a hacker just got a lot more believable!
I'm not 100% sure on how it works, as times change, and I haven't been there in over five years.
But it still sounds fishy.
Posted by: Yukon Gold at May 1, 2006 11:21 AM
I ride the GO every day and hardly notice the LED board.
I support the Harper and the Tories, and this doesn't bother me so much...let it go.
JasperPants
Posted by: JasperPants at May 1, 2006 11:30 AM
We could only wish Gerry Nichol's wife's name was Gloria - what a headline:
"Sic Gloria on Transit Monday!"
Posted by: Drained Brain at May 1, 2006 11:50 AM
“The reactionary is always willing to take a progressive attitude on any issue that is dead.”-Theodore Roosevelt
Posted by: davidson at May 1, 2006 02:06 PM
I'm told remote controls to do this are available for something like US$20 at Sam's Club. They are intended for the LED signs which said superstore sells to small businesses; and have a range of about 7 metres.
Posted by: Orange Mike Lowrey at May 2, 2006 04:40 PM